econstor zbw

Transkript

1 econstor Der Open-Access-Publikationsserver der ZBW Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft The Open Access Publication Server of the ZBW Leibniz Information Centre for Economics Wang, Judith Y.T.; Yang, Hai; Verhoef, Erik T. Working Paper Strategic Interactions of Bilateral Monopoly on a Private Highway Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No /3 Provided in Cooperation with: Tinbergen Institute, Amsterdam and Rotterdam Suggested Citation: Wang, Judith Y.T.; Yang, Hai; Verhoef, Erik T. (2003) : Strategic Interactions of Bilateral Monopoly on a Private Highway, Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No /3 This Version is available at: Standard-Nutzungsbedingungen: Die Dokumente auf EconStor dürfen zu eigenen wissenschaftlichen Zwecken und zum Privatgebrauch gespeichert und kopiert werden. Sie dürfen die Dokumente nicht für öffentliche oder kommerzielle Zwecke vervielfältigen, öffentlich ausstellen, öffentlich zugänglich machen, vertreiben oder anderweitig nutzen. Sofern die Verfasser die Dokumente unter Open-Content-Lizenzen (insbesondere CC-Lizenzen) zur Verfügung gestellt haben sollten, gelten abweichend von diesen Nutzungsbedingungen die in der dort genannten Lizenz gewährten Nutzungsrechte. Terms of use: Documents in EconStor may be saved and copied for your personal and scholarly purposes. You are not to copy documents for public or commercial purposes, to exhibit the documents publicly, to make them publicly available on the internet, or to distribute or otherwise use the documents in public. If the documents have been made available under an Open Content Licence (especially Creative Commons Licences), you may exercise further usage rights as specified in the indicated licence. zbw Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft Leibniz Information Centre for Economics

2 7, 7LQEHUJHQ,QVWLWXWH'LVFXVVLRQ3DSHU 6WUDWHJLF,QWHUDFWLRQVRI%LODWHUDO 0RQRSRO\RQD3ULYDWH+LJKZD\ -XGLWK<7:DQJ +DL<DQJ (ULN79HUKRHI Ã'HSWRI&LYLO(QJLQHHULQJ7KH+RQJ.RQJ8QLYHUVLW\RI6FLHQFHDQG7HFKQRORJ\+RQJ.RQJ Ã'HSWRI6SDWLDO(FRQRPLFV)DFXOW\RI(FRQRPLFVDQG%XVLQHVVGPLQLVWUDWLRQ9ULMH8QLYHUVLWHLW PVWHUGDPDQG7LQEHUJHQ,QVWLWXWH

3 Tinbergen Institute The Tinbergen Institute is the institute for economic research of the Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam, Universiteit van Amsterdam, and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. Tinbergen Institute Amsterdam Roetersstraat WB Amsterdam The Netherlands Tel.: +31(0) Fax: +31(0) Tinbergen Institute Rotterdam Burg. Oudlaan PA Rotterdam The Netherlands Tel.: +31(0) Fax: +31(0) Please send questions and/or remarks of nonscientific nature to Most TI discussion papers can be downloaded at

4 !"#% & ' ()!**+,*+-*').! "# # # # % & & & /!0" " " "" ( 3 " 45656"3"783" 6!696 :!9 ; ( " 1 1 6& 1 " 6" 1 < 1 "&"18 1

5 )2"""" 1 ) 1"6 1" 1" " 2 "" )"1 " " & & 8 " "> " > & 9> 2 " " > 2 2 " 1 " > >& " > " & " > > : ;? "A<>2"1" " 1 2 A :*BB,; " "1 "A #:*BB-; & # :*BB-; 1 > 1 :&! " ;" " 1:& ;"< " 1 " 1 1A 211 1" " & >1 < 1" ">> "621 &211"" 21 1 "1

6 " 51 ) 11&@ "&&@" ": ; 1 < 21> " "1:'9 ; 1 <""18 1'9 '9 1 " 21 & :*B--; " !& :*BB*; "11% ':+++;3 " " " 1 '9 "1 D :++*; 21 1 " 1" 21" '9 & :" ; " 1"1 36: 1 ; 2 1 " 11 1 " 3 1"" <3"" & 1" 1211" 4 1" 11 C

7 1(1 D ' 2 "& )"6 12 "" 6 "3" "1 ) " " " " " " " 2 1 1! 21 1 " 1 * 1 1 "/ 2 1 " " ' 0 0 τ 0 1"0 :; : ;" () τ τ 0 ( 1 ( : ;0 ) 3 " : ; :1; :;0" π *+ & :"1 '9 ;)> 1 "'9 () τ "1 " "/ () τ + + ) τ () τ + τ+ () τ + τ :*; :; :C; E

8 " ) * :E; )( ) 3 " &"11 : &"; "1" / < < + < + ) < :,; : ; )12:*;6: ;&"1 " " " '9 " '9 "'9 '9 >" 1"" "'9 : τ ; () τ < () τ () τ < () 6'9 ( τ ) / τ " ( τ ) ( τ ) :G; ( ) + + ) τ + τ + :-; * τ ( + ) + * :B; "'9 : τ ; () τ < () τ () τ < () 3 " 6'9 ( τ ) / τ " " ( τ ) ( τ ) :*+; ( ) + + ) τ + τ :**;,

9 * τ ( ) * :*; H () τ 1 1'9 ( 1111" 3θ * 3θ τ [ θ θ ] * * () "θ* τ θ θ θ* τ :*C; ) 21 & 1'"/ θ θ τ τ θ θ* ',, ' τ τ τ τ θ θ* ' ',, ' τ τ θ * θ* θ θ* ' ',, ' :*E; :*,; :* ; ** -.& 1 &" 2 < " 1"" "12 "@1 1 "" " " " 512 <"1 11 1" " "1 2 " > " 1 " 21 " < " 1 6 " " " """ "

10 3 1 " " : ; # " 3 ">11 " 1 & 21 4)!2" & 1& &1 " 4 ) " " " 1 2 4! """4. " " 1 "& & 4 "6 " :2 ;31" 11 9 & " 2"&2 1& "1 ) 1 " " " 1" "1 **+ ) & 6'9 " 1"" τ " "2/ ( τ ) ( τ ) + τ + + τ :*G; :*-; + τ :*B; G

11 " "/ π ( ( :+; 3 1 "1 ' θ τ θ θ* :*;! 1 I θ + ( + :; 3"1 ( ( I I π :C; *** / 4) "" 1 2 )" " " &" " 3 18 " : ; "31/ D3 ( ) ( ) π ' ( ( :E; 18 ( ) ' :,; " ' "21 1 H1/ -

12 ( ) ( ) π ' + ( + ( + (' ( ) ) +λ : ; " λ ( λ + ) H " 1 / π + π + ' + (' ( ) ) λ + λ + :G; :-; :B; :C+; :C*; 11")3) 121 λ I I ) " " " 1 " 2 : 1 1; "3"/ D3 I I I I I I ( ) ( ) ( ) I π + ( + ( :C; π + :CC; B

13 π + :CE; "21 ) 3 " > " > 1 3"" 1& 21 > " 1 1& " " 1 1" **0 1/ 4! 4)/" 2 1 " 6 1 4): 1&"" ;1 111" & 1" & 3)4) &" " ( ) ( ) ( ( )) π + ( + ( :C,; 4 2 1" " 1 ( ) " " " < 12 11& " " " "/ *+

14 D3 ( ) ( ) ( ( )) π + ( + ( :C ; 18 ( ) ' π ( ) + :CG; :C-; " ' " & 3" )3!"/ ' ( ( I :CB; "11 " 11&" 12:CB;2:C ; ( ) ( ) ( ) π ' ( ( + ( ( )) ( + ( :E+; π ' + + ( + :E*; * θ + * + + ( I :E; "18 1 "/ **

15 21 * + * ' * * + ( ) ( ) + θ θ* * * :EC; 1 21 " '9 "12:*C;< 1 " 1" 6 '9 ( τ ) 3 I " 1 1 "15 { I 3 D 21 } 1 3 I 9"1 D{ 21 } > + * θ + 3 :EE; 3 I 21 3 )3!1 1 & 2 :CB; 1 3"1"1 " 12 "11" " "< "> 8" "'9 ) 1 11&11 1<"" 3 6 "21: 2 ; 3 1& " 2 )&"1& :2 ; ) 1 :*B--;1 18 "1 2 " " *

16 **3 (/. 1 & 1>: ; :;< 1 " >3 : ; 4) 1 2:E;:,;9 " 4!12:C ;:C-;.211 **4 / <4" " 2 31 "31 "6" &" < " 2 " & 2 "> 11 4!1 2 &" " > / D3 ( ) ( ) ( ( )) π + ( + ( :E,; 18 ( ) ' π ( ) + :E ; :EG; " ' "21 2 ">51"1 4! 2:CB;:EE; *C

17 > 1& "> 2 / D3 ( ) ( ) π ' ( ( :E-; 18 ( ) ' :EB; " 2 H 1/ ( ) ( ) π ' + ( + ( + (' ( ) ) Jλ :,+; " λ ( λ + ) H "1 "/ π + ' + (' ( ) ) λ + λ + :,*; :,; :,C; :,E; 1" / */ λ + > + I * * * * * * * * + + :,,; *E

18 / λ + + I * * * θ + * :, ; C/ λ > + > + I * * * * * ' θ θ* * * * * + + :,G; E/ λ > + + I * * ' θ + θ θ * * * :,-; "11 " ) " 1 " 2 1> " > " 1& 21>5 " < > " " " > " > 2 ) 4! " 31& **5 / 18 " / D3 *,

19 π π +π ( ) ( ) ( ) + ' ( + ( ( ( :,B; 18 ( ) ' : +; " ' "21 H1/ ( ) ( ) ( ) π ' + ( + ( ) + ( + ( + ( +λ ' : *; / π ' + λ (( ) ( ) ' + π ' + λ + + λ (( ) ( ) ( ( + π ' + λ (( ) ( ) + ' + (' ( ) ) λ + λ + : ; : C; : E; :,; : ; : G; 11)3!" # < 21 1 " 1C" 21 1E *

20 0+ < "" KC*+ KE+, 0* / (*"1 " & >> ) " ) " ( * " > 1 :KE+ ; 1 9 "1 8 1 :K* ;1 " 1 1 " 9""11 4 "121 " ( * :KE+ K* ; "11& "> ">K,C KC* " " " " 12 &> / ) C"" *G

21 11& " " " " 2 " > >2 "( (C ) " ( C : 2 ; 1 " 1 ( " " 2 1 """"1< "" & " & )"(C2 " 1 > 1& ( 11 "" " " 6 1& " 1 " ) " 1 " 2 " 1 " " " > 1 3 " "" > & " ""(E 18 " > " 5 " 2 :1*+;" :K*+; *-

22 2 :,; : ; ) " 1 E 1 " 1& 21 1 " "12 1 1""> 1" 2 " "181" <"& 1 " > " "& 1 &" 1 1 " 12 " >81 3)" 1E "1 K*,2 * 3""1 )12 1" 3"1CEE+ 03 (/." "1& 2 21"1"" 4 ) : 1 2 :E; :,;; "4!:12:C ;:C-;; "3 1 1"" 2 " :4);" 12 :4!; "6 " (, 4 ) 1 " 4! 63 " 63 # " " 18 >6 "1:1 4!; > 21" " 9 " > " 6 3 " 1 12 " #""> *B

23 )#KE*K,* ">KEB+,EKC* " " KEG2 1**1 04 / ( " " > 1 1 4!3 2 &"1 " &" 2 " 1 " ( 1"2 ) < 2 "" >35< " 18 " 1 2 <*" K* 2, 3 " 1 C+- ""1KEGEE"K*- K-,, " / ) " "1 :KE+; +

24 KC- 2 " 1 CE 3 K GEB*" 3 KE+ " " < " <1 1 1 " 1 1 1" 06! )" 1E2 &21 " (, E 21 4 ) 4! 1)4! 3 1& < 4 ) " " 4!4 1 " " 1 L2> "."411& 2 " 3 5 " 214)"4! "4)"1 <2 214!"1:" "2 ;".:4;". 1 " " 2 21 "6""6 "2.:4; 3 11!" 2 " ":1 *

25 " L >1 ; <6""6:4 )!; 3 < 4 ) " 1 " 1 1@"9 4! 1 " 2 1 " 1 <. "1 & ">1 "1 1> 1 &" 1" 2 ""3 ""&"13 < " M: 2 > ;> 3 " " 1 % " 3+ <" " ) :D*BG; 8"1 ' N J 9 θ + τ * τ + τ τ +θ* + ' + + ' + + ( + ( + ( + ( + ' ( + ( : -; < 2 1 " 1

26 N # < 1 " " " 19 2 " 21:1 6'9 ;" 3* " 1C" 1 2.""81 " 1 )1 1"" "1 ) 1 ) " 1 " < "1 ""6 < ") M" 6 " 1 C " :K+ KE ; 2 :1, ; 8 :K*;" " " 2 <" ) " 1 C 4!> ! 1 6 D3""2 " )214! " 4" 18 C

27 31< 14! 9 1" 4) 21"1 1" 1 & ' 1" 1" " ( " 2 &21 4 )! 6" " &1"" "4) 4!4." 1& 4 "6 " " 1 ) " " " 1 " 121 " " 1 " 1 "<&!"16 " "1 & " " < ""2 :4! 4 ; " 1 "1 1 E

28 1 " " & 16 &"" 1 2 "@1@ "1 2"" ) 1 ( ) # "& 1 & 21 1 " " "& 1( 3 11& "" 1 1'9 1 1 D 6 1 " 1 '9 61D611 &"" 1" 1"" :1; 11 1" :1 ; 2 " 1 '9 " 3 < '9 6& " 111"&1 " " " 1" D " < 1' :*BBB;",

29 6 1 1 < 1 ""1 21( 2 " " 3 " " 1" "1 1 6 "1 <"1"" 21( " 3 < 11 3 > 3<"""11 36 " 2 " 1 1 ) 1"13! "1 &2 7 : ; ("" " " " @ 1 2 D 1 %11" 12 1 *+" 1 " 1 1 % 4 )%:#8. +CCM+;

30 #!& *BB* 6 1 " 8, &* *6*- *B--?! C6-* # *BB, #? % 9 -*C-G6E++ D *BG 9 1!.9(,B*6 +E ##)*BB- < " D&# - %)"!*6*G*BB- '& )+++&## %/# " D?++*'66 1! 9 7. /E**6EE G

31 ) * 1 1C D1 1 ) (* ( (C #14) ">4! ">4! (E >3 4! (, ">21 1 * )3) )3! )3 )3 21 4! " -

32 ! " # π ( + ) ( ) ( + ) + " ( ) "! % # ( ) π ( ) ( + ) % && & ' & () " &! & * + && &" ( τ),& τ + + τ () () τ + τ+ () τ + τ - % & (&) &

33 ( )! # () τ )( ( ) " #!( θ% ) '( #!( θ ) ( ) #( ) ( ) #( ) ( ) #( ) & # % * + #

34 !" #%& #% '% %& #%%* # %!" +, * &##,& )&& + + -!" + #&%* % &% #'% % )%# #%* -./ /" + '%) (%( * % % &*% #% *#%* -!" &% &% &% &% &% &% &% % /",#&' '# 0!/" + #,'&( *',#( +& 012!/", &,*,#(* #(,&# #',## 0!/" ),' ',) ''(,**( ',)#',' &,') +((!/" #, # &,'' '(,((' *&,*' *, * *(,*( (,& *, * %/ /",&( #' *'& %/ /",*),'',## *'*,)*,#,)'* %/ /",(#,#* * &*,*#( ( #,(* # 3 % 45 6, /1./4 +/./%./4 //44516% %/4127/41%

35 :12890! # /" * & # <./4/0 # & * ' 890! # /" 0;!& 0;! 0;! & 0;! 0;!& 0;! 0;!& 0;!# ;! ;!'( ;!&#) ;!) ' ;! )* ;! && ;! *# ;! )( ;! * ;!# ;!'

36 !" # %&& ' ' ('

37 )**' + (,* )**' ),*

38 )**' + (,* +

39 ) * ( # +&+,!"( +&+,!"#!"#%&'"!"(%&'"!")%&'"!"*%&'"

40 τ ( + ) + τ + τ + + τ + τ ( ) τ τ τ τ τ τ θ θ τ τ θ θ τ τ θ θ

41 ! " #% &')*& +, " π ( ( ( - #' + *)-+ '! ( (. - /0 * " *#" '' ###(! 0 0!( π + + τ θ τ τ + + ( ) θ θ θ θ θ θ - - %!!)0 ) '!( θ /"!! "! ( ( - %! +0*0 # % *0!! + '! τ τ θ θ - ( + ) + ( ) θ θ + + ( ) ( ) + θ θ - -

42 + + ( ) ( ) + θ θ - 1 %0!" '' #!% + '!!( * τ ( + ) + θ + θ + * - -

43 /" *# *#! π 3 ( ( 3 ( ( )) λ ( ( 3 λ 3 #% +)34 π λ ( ) 3 π τ τ τ τ ( λ ) θ θ θ θ 3 /"!!!0 ' '!! ##! 0 ""0!%! 0 ) 3) /!# %' *# 5 ## 0"0 5 0*0 #5 " '' #!!+, 05 "!!% 0 +0 ) /!#'! (5' "!! %#!!4 3! λ (678*0 > %! λ )30!#' (5' ! λ (678*0

44 τ %! λ )30! ( 0 ' τ θ (!#' (5. θ + 3 3! λ > (678*0 > 9 λ > ( "! %*!% 0 +( ( ( 3 τ τ θ θ 3 #' )3(5' θ θ ! λ > (678*0 ( τ θ (!#' )3(5'. θ + θ θ 3

45 τ θ θ τ θ θ τ θ θ τ τ θ θ τ τ θ θ τ θ θ τ ( + ) + τ + τ + + τ τ ( ) 8

46 τ τ 8 8 τ 8