BUNDESINSTITUT FÜR RISIKOBEWERTUNG Bewertung des Virulenzpotentials von Shigatoxin 2e (Stx2e) bildenden E. coli-st Stämmen Gladys Krause & Lothar Beutin
Shiga Toxin producing E. coli (STEC) More than 200 serotypes... Some of these can cause (bloody) diarrhea and HUS in humans Shiga toxin family, action similar to plant toxin ricin 28s RNA-N-glycosidase, cytotoxic activity, inhibition of protein biosynthesis, cell death and organ damage Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 2
Stx1 & Stx2 Families Stx1 family Stx2 family stx-gene gene bank access. no stx-gene gene bank access. no stx 1 M16625 stx 2 X07865 stx 1-CB168 Z36900 stx 2c (stx 2v-ha ) AJ605767 stx 1-O48 Z36899 stx 2d-ount AF043627 stx 1-OX3 (stx 1c ) Z36901 stx 2-Ox3:H21 X65949 stx 1d AY170851 stx 2-OX392 L11079 stx 1d-like AY986980-82 stx 2e M21534 stx 2f AJ010730 stx 2ev (stx 2f-like ) M29153 stx 2g AY286000 stx 2-NV206 AF329817 stx 2 & stx 2c M59432 & M76738 stx 2d1 & stx 2d2 (stx 2d mucus activatible ) AF479828 + AF479829 Stx-Variants with high virulence Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 3
Stx1 family: three major subgroups Stx1a + Stx1b Stx1c Stx1d genetic distance Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 4
Stx2 family: five major subgroups Stx2b Stx2e Stx2f Stx2g Stx2a, stx2c, + activatable stx2d Closely associated with HC and HUS Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 5
The major reservoir for STEC in nature are animals, often used for food production stx1b stx2b stx2c stx1c stx2b Major variants of the Stx1 and the Stx2 family are associated with distinct animal host species Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 6
Shigatoxin 2e The P27 Phage carries the Stx2e-Gene Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 7
Possible role of Stx2e as human pathogens Stx2e Stx2e 19% of STEC isolated from food in Germany* 0.9% of patients with STEC in Germany** *Beutin L, et al. AEM 2007 73:4769-75 **Sonntag AK, et al. AEM 2005 71:8855-63 **Beutin L, et al. JCM 2004 42: 1099-1108 Many humans with Stx2e strains have no symptoms of gastrointestinal disease no significant association between Stx2e infection and diarrhea*** ***Friedrich AW, et al. JID 2002 185:74-84 Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 8
Risk Assessment of 110 Stx2e strains from different sources for their role as human pathogens Sources of Stx2e producing strains Stx2e Human patients (9) pigs at slaughter (25) cause of edema disease in pigs edema disease principle diseased pigs (19) meat, milk (36) soil, water (21) Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 9
Risk Assessment of 110 Stx2e strains from different sources for their role as human pathogens Properties of Stx2e producing strains Sources of Stx2e producing strains Human patients (9) Stx2e production Stx2e-bacteriophage Virulence markers serotypes Stx2e pigs at slaughter (25) meat, milk (36) soil, water (21) diseased pigs (19) Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 10
Stx2e production as measured by ELISA 70 60 60% 68% 61 50 Without induction no. strains 40 30 34 37 25 With mitomycin C 20 10 20 9 13 14 6 0 1 undetectable weak moderate strong very strong Stx2e production Stx2e production is low in most strains without induction, but inducible by mitomycin C Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 11
Comparison of representative high and low Stx2e producers Stx ELISA (P1-g-EIA) No induction + Mitomycin C Strain ELISA Highest dilution +ve ELISA Highest dilution +ve CB10282 undetectable - weak 0 CB10284 undetectable - weak 0 CB10394 weak 1:4 Very strong 1:2048 CB10402 weak 1:2 Very strong 1:1024 2771/97 moderate 1:32 Very strong 1:4096 2771/97 = reference strain carrying stx2e phage P27 Recktenwald J + Schmidt H. IAI 2002 70:1896-1908 Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 12
stx2e gene sequence identity in high and low Stx2e producers CB10282 CB10284 CB10394 CB10402 low high 2771/97 966bp 264bp Highly similar to stx2e gene present on inducible stx2e bacteriophage P27 strain 2771/97 Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 13
Differences in Stx2e production are related to mrna transcription rates of stx2e genes in high and low producing strains. RT-PCR relative quantification No induction + Mitomycin C Strain ELISA Ratio stx2ea over icda gene expression ELISA Ratio stx2ea over icda gene expression CB10282 undetectable 1.0 ± 0.0 weak 1.0 ± 0.2 CB10284 undetectable 0.16 ± 0.1 weak 1.0 ± 0.2 CB10394 weak 2.01 ± 0.4 Very strong 1179.0 ± 286 CB10402 weak 1,19 ± 0.0 Very strong 9.84 ± 0.8 2771/97 c moderate 5.71 ± 2.9 Very strong 151.86 ± 17.7 Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 14
Phage P27 is the origin of stx2e genes in strains of different serotype, origin and pathotype 95 (86.4%) 40 (36.4%) presence 20 (18.2%) 44 (40%) 109 (99.1%) strains carried P27 specific gene sequences, only 7 (6.4%) were positive for all P27 sequences searched here. Cryptic phages or recombinants are frequent Quantity of Stx2e production was not dependent on the integrity of the P27 genome or presence of genes like Q or presence of trna region upstream of stx2ea. Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 15
Stx2e strains from humans do not belong to serotypes most frequently found in food, pigs and in the environment 14 12 31 10 10 slaughter pig 8 6 4 5 10 18 10 8 4 5 meat/milk environm diseased pig human feces 2 2 7 0 O138:H14 O139:H1 O141:H4 O100:H30 O8:H9 O8:H4 O8:H19 O2:[H32] O101:H9 NT Single* diseased pigs pigs, food, environment humans, pigs, food, environment Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 16
>50% of Stx2e strains are positive for heat stable enterotoxins (STI, STII and EAST1) that could play a role in diarrheal disease 18 16 18 14 12 10 8 1 2 9 17 alpha-hly F107 St-P ST-B 23,6% 21,8% 54,5% 6 4 2 5 6 1 3 6 EAST 0 O138:H14 O139:H1 O141:H4 O100:H30 O8:H9 O8:H4 O8:H19 O2:[H32] O101:H9 NT Single* diseased pigs pigs, food, environment humans, pigs, food, environment Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 17
Are Stx2e strains pathogenic for humans? All stx2e strains are negative for other types of Shiga toxins. Strains producing only Stx2e are not associated with diarrhea or HUS in humans. Diarrhea in humans infected with Stx2e strains could be caused by heat-stable enterotoxins that are present in more than 50% of the natural Stx2e isolates. The major serotypes of Stx2e producing strains present in pigs, in food and in the environment are frequently occurring and it is likely that humans get in contact with these. In contrast, these strains are very rarely isolated from humans indicating that most of these cannot colonize/or cause disease in the human host. Gladys Krause, 04.04.2008, Fortbildung für den Öffentlichen Gesundheitsdienst Seite 18
DANKE FÜR F R IHRE AUFMERKSAMKEIT BUNDESINSTITUT FÜR RISIKOBEWERTUNG Gladys Krause Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung Thielallee 88-92 D-14195 Berlin Tel. 0 30-84 12-0 Fax 0 30-84 12-47 41 bfr@bfr.bund.de www.bfr.bund.de