Solar Energy for Process Heat: Workshop report from the Sol-Ind Swiss project Martin Guillaume (martin.guillaume@heig-vd.ch) Marco Caflisch (marco.caflisch@spf.ch) 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11th 2018, Rapperswil (Switzerland)
Introduction Sol-Ind Swiss Project Push the deployment of solar process heat in Switzerland focussing on the heat demand at low temperature levels (<130 C) Identify the potential and suitable industrial sectors Audits and Feasibility study in selected companies P&D systems Switzerland 855 PJ consumed in 2016 (645 PJ th ) 2,5 PJ th from solar thermal systems 6 SHIP systems already implemented: Dairy products manufacturing; Machinery products manufacturing; Bitumen production Data on energy consumption Corresponding to the year 2016 Swiss Overall Energy Statistic GEST, established by the Swiss Federal Office of Energy NOGA classification for industry sectors Laboratory of Solar Energetics and Building Physics www.lesbat.ch 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11 th 2018 2
Swiss Industry Energy Consumption Industry Energy Consumption by Energy Vectors SWISS ENERGY CONSUMPTION in 2016 Swiss Heat Consumption 75% 11% 7% Industry Energy Consumption Swiss Electricity Consumption 25% Industry energy consumption Around 155 PJ Accounting for 18% of the total Swiss final energy consumption Industry heat consumption 66% from fossils fuels 14% from renewable energies 59% Heat 41% Electricity Gas 43% Oil 18% Wood 12% Laboratory of Solar Energetics and Building Physics www.lesbat.ch Ind. Waste 12% District Heating 8% Coal 5% Other RE 2% 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11 th 2018 3
Energy Consumption [PJ] Swiss Industry Energy Consumption Process Heat Consumption APPLICATION ENERGY CONSUMPTION by ENERGY VECTOR in 2016 INDUSTRY THERMAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION by APPLICATION in 2016 100 80 Heat Electricity 2% 8% 21% Space Heating and Hot Water 60 40 40% 1% Process Heat 20 0 13% Space Heating and Hot Water 14% 5% Process Heat Lighting, Home Automation and ICT 22% Mechanical Work 5% Electrolysis, Environmental Protection and Others 69% Mechanical Work Electrolysis, Environmental Protection and Others Process Heat Application 85 PJ (54% of the industry consumption) 75% from heat and 25% from electricity Laboratory of Solar Energetics and Building Physics www.lesbat.ch Potential considering Heat demand for process heating 63 PJ th 40% of the industry consumption 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11 th 2018 4
Solar Heat Potential for Industrial Processes Promising Industrial Sectors INDUSTRIAL SECTORS THERMAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION by APPLICATION in 2016 INDUSTRY HEAT CONSUMPTION in EU-27 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% Electrolysis, Environmental Protection and Others Mechanical Work Process Heat Space Heat and Hot Water 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 61% 32% Food Textile / Clothing 34% Paper and printing 40% Chemical / Pharma <6% Too low Minerals Metals Promising Industrial sectors considered Those with high share of heat demand for process heat Food, Textile/Clothing, Paper, Chemistry/Pharma LT (<100 C) MT (100 400 C) HT (>400 C) Based on Pardo et al. (2012) Laboratory of Solar Energetics and Building Physics www.lesbat.ch 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11 th 2018 5
Solar Heat Potential for Industrial Processes Theoretical Potential in Swiss Industry Industrial Sector Thermal Energy Consumption SH and HW [PJ] Process Heating [PJ] Low Temperature Demand (<100 C) Low Temperature Heat Demand [PJ] Theoretical Potential [PJ] Food 1.6 8.8 61% 6.3 4.7 Textile/Clothing 0.2 0.6 32% 0.3 0.1 Paper 0.5 5.7 34% 2.1 1.6 Chemistry/Pharma 2.3 17.7 40% 8.0 5.7 Theoretical potential for low temperature SHIP systems in these four industrial 12.1 PJ 8% of the Industry energy consumption 1.4% of the Swiss energy consumption Laboratory of Solar Energetics and Building Physics www.lesbat.ch 7 th Swissolar Solar Heating Conference September 11 th 2018 6
Methodik Methodik des Projekts angelehnt an Task 49 Fragebogen mit einfach Fragen zur Entscheidung Go / No Go: Temperaturniveau & Prozessverbrauchsprofil Verwendung von fossilen Brennstoffen Freie Dachfläche & Orientierung Wärmerückgewinnung Amortisationszeit Motivation Source: Muster B. et all, 2015. Task 49 Integration Guideline 7 Marco Caflisch
Antworten auf Fragebogen 483 Unternehmen wurde der Fragebogen geschickt 54 Firmen haben teilgenommen, hauptsächlich aus der Deutschschweiz Sprachregion Anzahl Antworten Lebensmittel Textil Papier Chemie/ Pharma CH-FR 10 5 0 1 4 CH-IT 3 2 1 0 0 CH-DE 41 26 8 2 5 Total 54 33 9 3 9 8 Marco Caflisch
Thermische Energie und zeitlicher Bedarf nach Temperaturbereich Teilnehmer aus dem Papiersektor entsprechen nicht den Resultaten der EU-Studie (Pardo et. al 2012) Hoher Bedarf auf Temperaturen <100 C bei Firmen aus den anderen Sektoren 9 Marco Caflisch
Weitere Erkenntnisse 38% fordern Amortisationszeiten von 3-5 Jahre für Wärmeerzeuger mit erneuerbaren Energien 25% akzeptierten auch >7 Jahre zu Kein Zusammenhang zwischen Anzahl Mitarbeiter bzw. Industriesektor und der Länge der Amortisationszeit 35% aller Unternehmen antworteten Solarthermie in der Wärmeerzeugung berücksichtigt aber nicht umgesetzt zu haben Berücksichtigung: Textilbranche 44%, Lebensmittel 36% Chemie/Pharma 22% Für 63% dieser Unternehmen sprachen wirtschaftliche Gründe gegen die Umsetzung 10 Marco Caflisch
Ausblick Anhand von 10 Audits die geeignetsten 3 Unternehmen definieren Unverbindliche Grobplanung eines standardisierten Solarthermie Anlagenkonzepts Kollektortyp, Kollektorfeldgrösse, Hydraulik- & Monitoringkonzept, Prozessintegrationslösung, etc. Ertrags- und Kostenrechnung Solargewinne am Standort, Brennstoff- & CO2-Einsparung Systemkosten, Amortisationszeit & Wärmegestehungskosten Erarbeitete Konzepte & Know-how werden Anlageplanern weitervermittelt 11 Marco Caflisch
Danke für die Aufmerksamkeit 12 Marco Caflisch