+., -/ '01 2-., ., '3

Transkript

1 ! "##$

2 ( ' )*+ ', '&-., +., -/ '01 2-., ()20., '3.,., 45&1 & 0 +&6 7,)7&!" # 89!" ## : &%6 ;%.&!" # $$$%& %'

3 !!"!#!!$! "#! "$##%&$ ' & '! "( ) "* +, + * $ $ / 1 0!20*3 #4$! "5"! " ' & ""$' 6, 6 * $ $ 8(( # '0 # 9 #( /, / * $ -. / 1 + 0$ , 7 + * $ $ $!#!" +.:' ; + # / + 3)"3"$ #<9##" / + # = + () 9##"2>). # <# 6 ++ &) ( & ()' + &33 += +7 +! "#? ''# / + & ""# /+

4 ++! " &?? 3 &)' /1 /1 +1.$' -! "2A ' >)' /= += 0 (! "#' ' 0 / (3 3'#' ' ##( 1 %! # & / -$("! "#% 1 / B&0 (! " "" )3 " $ % 11 / &(? &! " 11 / &(? 0 (! " 16 # & '!#( ) 1 C' 1 -"3 0( = = 1 < =+ 1 "3&$ =/ 1+ (@ 0( "# 3 0( =1 1 C"# == ' 7 1/ 0) 11 0( 6 ) '!*!+( = C"# + = 1 = ' 7 =+ 0), ) -.

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

6 &7;* " H BI) 8! "0 + &+;* (@ H $ / &+;* (@ H 1 &+;& ')(' 0) = &+;#& "6 &++;&&((0 & F$? 3) 7 &+/;&(' )! " 7 &+1;&(' )! " &+=; ;0$ &((&? &+6; )! ";0$ &((&? &+7; ''9(#+ &/; ''9( = &/; ''9( ' &/; ''9( + ' C" >;.$' &" #<9##"6 >;.$'< # #<9##" J0 7 >+;.$' J- &" 0) ++ >/;.$'$&. # 3) &76771+= >1;.$'&$. # 77= += >=;.$'* )&?3 &/ >6;C(0 F) &?-)/ >7;>)'! ") ">)'/6 >;0 $< # "&6 >;* >;0( 7 >;C)0( 7+ >+;H' )< 7/ >/;H' )C) 71 >1;#&)< 7= >=;#&)C) 76 >6;* < 77 >7;* C) 77

7 " & '! "( " & ""$' (J>#D! "$##E * B '@( #H$#"-! "#? ''#$- ()! " / "K ' # # < 9##" " K $ &. ') (@ -## $ - "$ $ J $ #J! ""K # (& ' 0 ' >)'#&@ * #9 #LC##&( 0# # (@ 4 " 0C4 D4 "# & ' ) " 0 ()' E ( # (4(-; -##(@ &( "# >#& ""$' $ 0 $ # J $&M &$! " & ' 0 J -##(. '9#3(J?'( F$.I "J( (@ 0 (.(" # 4 -##(@ &( #(I $ # J>#'@(! " (J! ) "* "# 4 $ ( ## J0(@. )" ' '@(* " $ 'B &( I '$ #<(:3"H$ #)?? 33" '"J4 #

8 . M# # ( C '#; 3)"9##" () 9##"<# &) (! "#? ''# &33! " -! "2A ' >)' 0 (! "#' ' 0 0 (3 3'#' ' 0 H C ( &M &M ;, ## $C' ". J>( $ 0$ " ( &(? # &A$ "0$ M#"## (J#4# $ J " M" )* ) " 0 ("$! "##B!"! #$! -. # C(@ ' ' 0 ( )'&(0(? ) " & "$ ' >)' F? ) "& "$' >)'" &( " &$ &'##'J$ F? $? ##" & "$ ' >)'(? J#" M# $ 3' 0( ( & ' ) ">)'$0 0 & $ $' )! "! " 0$ ##

9 "$ >)' " (?) ( &A # $ 0 C H 0) ( 0( ( #K&+@ $$$ " # $ +7 "$ # $ +17! ""$#! "( H< " 0$ #' >)' < < "( >#( &(# $ &$ '.,49, $ &((&? # # 9' (? ()' ("J? #'! "#J (( <' ' 0 (" "$ 0 $ *# $ 0 (! " * (@ ) K ( * #9 3 " # (.$' * ) 3 " # 4$ ( &! "(@ ' 0 #B& ' $ J3', J.$ ')K ) '$, '" I () # 9' ( &! " ") ("J $> J#'#& # < 9##" "" I 4#" F) &33 " * (@- 3 ) BA > & C" J ) " * 3 K 3""' &" ' )! " " "##! "J 3 '" $! " <) "#&" 4 33,# ("<) "M#0 ")

10 8) #'? # "$ C#@.$' # ) ' 0 #? # BA, (( 0 ( $ (@ &M0$ )(.? )", N(" -&)#J$ $"' >)'J$@$ # -<' J(! "! "$ $ J B & ' ) " 0 (J "0# # * '0 (#<#< ".$ &3'J 3 #)"$ J ((< M# ((@ &! "J >)' # 9' (, 0) )J, I& ( $ IG) J " J ## $! "' ) ")$ #9'(#"J #(? :""$(0 "' &('#@ ( J< C)? # $ ' $ # (( # I &! "! "& &" C" &# #& 3'.$'CA#J#! "# $ 'J 0'$ % & M. 0$ $ 0( '(@(9( (" $ J (@ #LC##3(J(CA#" (; +

11 - " #3(#LC#M#' C $ '",# $G # # " 'J & "M# (( $ J, ) )J&" # 3" 03$' 0, ( "$ ("& " I " # ) &$# () $. B I G) 0 "(@,. $' &33 "$'#)AJ # ) '? :" #" J # # -##0 '* ) +.&&3"<' " < $) &"(@ ". /.&O2 C &$ # '(@! "G("? 9"$ $ #3" 1 $(@ - (@ -# 3 & '@ "&" 33"$ #B&(. = & & "# (: &" # CB' >")( $) & J C$K " J, >)'" 6 &3 " 0## 0 (@ )'( & ' >''$ 2 C@ G(" #B$ 7."? <@ ' )($' )" J & " * ) ">)'" /

12 .$' * ) <@ ' '3 <@ ' ) $(@ -( #& 3""B "? $'J (@ C 3 ) $< ">#? F'## $ (&3' 3# & 3 "# ' # 0"(0$)) " &(3$ & > ' 0@ ( 0)( # ' $ C. & " 3 & ') ' ) " >)'. 3 & < #B''B>D& ')3'E$ * (@ ' KB M# DK E.$' <B 3 ## (@ ') "@? $' #B ((" & " & + #9'(0"(( 0 (((" & "$ P #("' H! " /.4? &M"0&$ I) ' " J ( 4#A# " $' 2 #B (@ * ) ' " 1 ' ##' * I& 0) "0 # " #'#3'B* & ') #$ = & &( < " ') J 1

13 ! "# J ' & " (@ F C" J ' ) ")"$ =

14 " & '! "(" & ""$' (J>#D! "$##E * B '@( # H$# " 3 J 0# *. 4$ #.$ $ J,.49"# 0 ( ').$' ) (-#0(3JK & ' C" "$ BA 3' C -&*+ I" (( # ( 0) " -$ & ""## J! " "K $ 0C4 -"##" H$ "J > #' $ 3 -! " #? ''#$- ()! " /"K ' J$-. # #<9##" "K $ &. ') (@ -## $ - "$ $ J! " "K # (& $ #& ' 0 '&'@( 0 (! "#$ ( ) " & $ 3 #.$' <B(('' #()(J$ "# > ( " $ -# "$ J 3 "$! "# * 3) < #& P '3").'.)"J3' (3"(, F"" " &( I '$ #<(:3"H$ #)?? 33" '"J4 # 6

15 &4 #B $ ' 0 ()'$ #&#( & &. M#, -##)"$& ""J& "$0 ("( #& ' 0 ()' " #-# #"#&#A&#@ $, " ( J F'.) "0"( "$:! "# " #B 4 "$> J " $ ( (>&$ " J# >#' "J - C' 0(@ )& $ 0$ J " 4 J ## #. # ; &( "#>#! "# &M " 0" ( C'J 0"M#J '@( 0 ( "$C)"$ "##( 0$ # &M 0$ "C" & "".)"@ CB'J(0 )? " (( > 0 "$ $ $ &$! " & ' 0 M - # -$' $ # K & +0( (@ J 0( (. >&( - 0( $ JC? J ) " & (J (@ ' ' ) "0 ()'& ' ) " >)'" #&( 4 $ ACA # 9#3( J #! "# $ ' 7

16 4 > 4 #( I $ # J >#'@(! " (J! ) " * "# 4 $ ( ## J 0(@.)" ''@(* "$ 'B.M# # ( C '#; 3)"9##" () 9##"<# &) (! "#? ''# &33! -! "2A ' >)' 0 (! "#' ' 0 0 (3 3'#' ' 0 H C ( &M &M ( ;, ## $C' ". J>( 0$ " ( &(? # &A$ "0$ M#"## (J#4# $ J " M" )* ) " 0 ("$! "##B

17 ,#.)" "4 " & ""C" #"'BJ$ ( $#43 )3 ( (@ ; I) "0" ') "'## J 0#I)# J - (@ * 3)"-* J - (@ & #-&* 0 (@ & (@ #"3 C?? #"<') &M 0$ (&( 3? $ 0$ G #9'(F')J*)3 ))." )? '@(0 (! ""$? "#C! "#(&( (@; &@.$' & "" &" 0 $ #3)"" -' )! "" < &@ '@(0 ( M#.$'# (.$'J* '0 (<#2>")(J.(@ 4J,#".49, J& & "$! "(?(

18 !#!/ 0 1"! ambulant/ stationär regional differenziert Versorgungssituation mit kurativ tätigen Ärztinnen und Ärzten in Deutschland fachspezifisch differenziert Berücksichtigung von Fehlallokationen Bedarf Angebot Arbeitsorganisation Anzahl der Fachärzte EuGH-Urteil Teilzeitbeschäftigung Anzahl der Ärzte in Weiterbildung Vereinbarkeit von Familie und Beruf Nachfrage nach Ärzten aus nichtkurativen Bereichen in Deutschland/ Ausland Gesundheitspolitische Zielvorstellungen (z. B. Versorgungsgrad) Drop-Outs Anzahl der kurativ tätigen Ärzte Anzahl der Approbationen Anzahl der Absolventen im Fach Humanmedizin Anzahl der Studierenden im Fach Humanmedizin Zuflüsse/ Zuwanderung Gesundheitssystemrelevante Entwicklungen (z. B. DRG, int. Vers.) Bevölkerungsentwicklung/ Demografische Entwicklung Anzahl der Studierenden im 1. Fachsemester Humanmedizin Anzahl der Bewerber/ innen im Fach Humanmedizin Anzahl der Studienplätze im Fach Humanmedizin &;C" 0 * #' )! " 2'3!! &. I?' J '##>#! "#)(I $I (#I "0 $ " C *"? # B((J ( : "$ $ * 3)0) (# '##? # 40. )( 3+0

19 <"# $) ) "* #'@( 0 (! " 4 $ &M; 9J, G<) 33, ) <9 "( #&/2J9 9J,, &M 9 JK! "#! "$##%&$ ' & '! "( ) "* ( & J0 3J>#4$! " 5. &( " & ' & ""$' 0*0 ) "'## B 3J>! "( P H$#" < =62J==6 (( #JC '0 # 9 #( 'J@ (

20 !!"!#!! &$'$' &$'$( 4 " /!/ 1(! 0 % "?' ( & '(>#! "# J &( 0!20* $ "# ) "* (@( 0) $0M $#* &M$ (00# ) "* ")* &A$ &$ ' & '! "( * $ (@ 9J< ) "$ J&)J&J99H! "JO J 3), (' )#(.?' ') "0 (3 ) * (@ F 0) ((@( ; 0 ';9 $ (@ F & " M3F?' '* 0 (3! " ''$? * #K ;.$ * (@ F?' & "M3 J J$& "" #1F)! "( $ <' J0 ( 0B' "$* ).$ 2& "8$ '## 03(0? # ;9 $ " ) ((J# &! " $ * ($ +

21 &$'$& + C ;<@ 9) "J J< ) " ) "$ J$ * "GQJ/Q11Q(@ ( $ & "" / )#0B' 3 ;9 $ ' )#0 B' 3 0#(@ 0$# (@ "$ $ F C"? * " *# & "?' < 33 ' I) $ # ) " #( ) "0, J $ P C & ) $ )K "#P H$' "F8F0?' 8B < $ 9 "" 0) #@"#" # $ " $ J " 0M " $ #) "0 '", B I) '##J $ J( $ " $ " " $ ($J 3$ ) $! " " $@ ##$ $ 'J( $ ""J J 4 "", ($ ' " J#@? #?' ' # ( B 4 ## CA# $. 933 # $ "# J ( $ & ""$ (J<'( $ & )#IB3 & /

22 &$'$+ 0 0$ 0 3" ; 0 (.? ' $, "$P #I $ '& & "M3$ ' J"0#9'(< J$&$ ' #) " &( ) H # "J :3"$ & 0 (? 0B' " $#J$ ( "$ ( #$9$(* "?' 0) $ 0M J F 'A( (3 # &#D J#. $ J! "J D1 ) E J# 3 '",#$) 1J AJ" $#-3' $ J $ F -# & 16 K (@? :( #* "# 4#B' 1/ K & " " J "##16IF J)$ #4J "" 0 (( #"$&( 0!20* #& 1K 71 J#3 ##16 8# #C J8(@ 3 " * "#K / 'B H? :( $ ' $ D&(@E ) "* 0 0 "" $ # #JQJ/Q11Q ( $ & ""$ " $ 'B $ 0 -#B J$ + 0"@ 0 ( ("$ ' )#? 0B' $'J $ F C# 1

23 " 0B' " $ ' ## "$3 > (J$40M # &( 7 0B' $#" "$ #3 " $ / * )"" * 3$ ## C '##* ) & ' #* ($ ( 0$ F" 3 " ( 0 (3 ( DP E#* Q $, /Q <) ""$=/Q9) " $ ( & " F )" $ "$ # * J 3$ $")# '' )( * F # 9 4M#! " ') J* ) "! "# J' -)" 0 & " B & " 0 " #* ")" (, "$C # #9' (J$&$ '? :(& * G) " 3 ; &' J# # )#H)) " * # $ 0 # &A ) (J ( & 3 $ GJ "4 &# $C ' " $ J ((&# "> $$)* )G03 (16(&? :(J0 $'@ ( " J ( 0 $ &) ' >)'$(." (? =

24 &$($' < 3 )) 0" ( & J ' 3 (@ $ G #* ((& " ( 0) ( # 0 #. * # ' $ "$ 3J &$ 0) F P (@ I) # B '(") ', ( $ J ) F " "J) 0) ' C; & ( 3 # &# C " '## J' 0 I) ( '"3 $ < *) # ' $ $ (@ #"#"J* # ) "* J $ $. ((' )G $)? #''@ " &? * ' J$) 0 3 $ BA> 0 3'-#$ < J$( 0 (3 #9'(#"< 0B' $')GJ' #16:6#36+7 8"!;!!1<!1/!3 / % " 3, "$J' &( J 0) "'## ) " 0 0!20* #K (@ B(( 4.$'&"& '! " #C3' < J '##K! "# #."$ ;.* =1Q 0 #& "6= 6

25 &$($( &$($&.$' & '! "R.$'#"H$R $.$'##$ +#) ' 0 R /.$'3" & " 339) "J ) " R 13"(! "R =& '! "$ 6-$ )! " ". $' & ""$ ## "$&( ' J$ F ' " #9 '.$' & ""' ) ( &$ ').. $ ## $ ## #0#J 0) "'## $# (@ #"3 $ N 9 #( ' J0 MJ " *# - 0( >J! " # &, (" P! "(J "##4"' & / F)! " ' J H$3 # (@ #"? (",# #?)# ( 4 " J " ).$' #" H$ " J - 3)"77 '& ( H &33 # ( ##& 3)"#" "? "" + 2 J$D-## * E$ $ +.$'' )(-*"#2+ $ "'@' -"J -$#* "#2& "'-"# 7

26 -#$ ' J - C" "$ 77 # "$ J1Q (.$'* ( - () & - 3" "$ 8$ " ') > $ &M " # '##" #. J. # F ) K 76777/ " "J$"" &"$ 1& #K 77/ P.$'", ( * #J ( $ (@ " $ ; D* "$ $ H #B'J #B $ ' & # ' 3 :( #3( &J C@"#3) # # $ E3; H - $.$' -! "#? ''#3 # "$77+@'#'33Q("-# $ H") #? ''#"$ J? ''# ' #&#J - & #? # #C C"3)" "$ J J &"# #' 0 )$ $.#B, (@ J " K ># ( #& # ' J # & ' 0 ( " >)' #?$ 0 &(# '#'$# 0 (' < 9##"' J"$ "$ () #<< $ #* ( #&# &FJ D<# E $ A $) ) " +#* 3)" )(

27 33&, #* ' <#0 (,#.)" " $.$'! """ J$ ## &(? #* J (&#" ; G$ ( J? &" * < " ' ( # H3 ' K *! "(#) ' 'J J # ) ' $ # $! "B$ + 16F)! " $ J )K #)A & K /.$ JF! "J)K 16IF J"#K $ 1 )K * ) ". 16IF * K?! "#"< " 33# K / J <F ($ 4 33$ #-##"$&( (J 3 ".$' )$ '& ""(@ < " 339) "J< ) " J &) "J ) "J! "?M 3 # K ((J $ ( '- & " &( # 4?M 3 'B3$"'##' "?M?M 34 (@! " J# &#A$" (#4" '## -### < "" " # J ## " #! "# (@ #J 4 #0 )#"# & P (@ $ ) ' $4 #@! "# ( "3 #" $

28 &$($+ #-## $? # 0) (@ 9) "J )K "$+Q1Q$? # J$* (' 9) "J 0) J & " 33@ ##$ ' H 9) " ( ) " J'## "#J( ' " * & " " $ #'H$##' # 0 (* ) "@ * $ (@ $ "$<' #; # ($ #"< #9'(# "-'("$! "B.(('$ & 4 (J # B C# ) J@ '#3 0 ( B$ ' "( #"< J $ ) CA#")"" & 4(. CB'J! "# (' " # J -$ )! " $ - )! "J # '' J" "@ # ( 3.)" J##BI@' ) "* $ 'B '##"#J ( J$ #! "" ' >)'"$. 0'##! "" (A ( # CA(@ "&, " & ' & ""$'J ".$' #" H$ $".$' # #' ( &M) ' $ & $ #( 'B ## $@$ >(0 $ #-##F#> 3 "F'

29 @ N) " ( -# " # 'J J $#'' J9? # >J 0 * " #(@ 0 C"# K 77 $)$ $' " J$&( " K " 3"'3")#K 77"# #K 77." (((K 77#"##)J 0#@ ' " (@. # # 77277'@. $' &" 4# )& I) "'## 0) 'B & "" 77 <' ( * J $) &M0 ( ' "'##0 $ * CA(@ "'@(0 ( ( <' $ # ( #" < $ "$ # #-##(7' 0B' -.((' & 4( " 0;" #C# ) $ ($ (@ $J$(? # 9' ( # ( 0776 * # '# &$ '#"< & #G & ;. $ &# * # (' J N(" " $.(('$ ## " (* 3 "'@(.$' "# ( # 0 "& * $ CA > 3 "3 )"J$. C 3 0 J.((' $ ' $ ' #) ' (@ )- ) ( $ * ( BJ $ ) # ' ) J "CB! #0

30 &$ ' ( # '? ' (@ G".49, " ) " & " 0 ( $ (@ <.(@ <) '&$ '## G( " $ JC ( #? # ( 0" J. #. )'" &3'CAJ#4(! "#") "J! "" $ * <)$ " 0 "'@(" $.$' G * C " &) 3$) &MN( " 0(' ( 0 ($@$.'"(#-## &M ) "J'! "#( '9 $ # J#D0 (E"# 3* J F')" #("J$(@ 0$! " <' ' A0 0 $$(@ < " 33(@ 3$ $ # 0, (( " 0$ (@ 0) # #&M () # ) ' &"! "J"! " ' $" -$ )! ""# ' O $) $ 0 >($ (@ "$& " 33( 9 $ "$ (, "$ ) ' $ 4 0 )# $J & # F$G & >( (@, ( "#0"(& '! "J, # -## 'B ")"&(@ P,,#< #" $! "##( "$ J#@ #3: -$ ) +

31 &$&$' &$&$(! " $ ( " &3' A " $ M. $) ( J # ((' 3 9 )""(" "6=5((7 86/#*'( % " - $ J ') ' ) ( #"#' '" * (@".$ * ( <3M# J 0.$'? A & "3 ') ##$ " '@($ ( ') " $ 0 ') 9F ) -' "# $ ( 3 )3 (0( #67 # ') / ' ) 0) +Q 0 ) 6Q 0 J$(@ 0 BA' (@ 0 ) F$ 3 )& (($ 9 0 BA' $ &( ' ) #"0J0J10J# 1 0 #3 (@ 3 ' 33 / 4 #. 0( # ') 0) #&# ') J"" ') #)AS640*B J#&# # ') J$?' ') 9''@ * (@ H ( ') # A 3M 2 0J > H''0$ ' ') J )#"# ') ") /

32 &$&$& 0 ') #"# 4 BA;) ') # # 1 3 ($J ' ') #3 $ ') 1 0 ( 0" * (@ ') 0) 3 ",# 0 " $ "# 3 )& 4 #$ "'BJ$ 3 ' 4$ 3 (@ 4$ ( C '# 0 0 BA' *#? ( ') # I( K ) $ #* " 1Q ') $ *' )()(J=Q ') #? J1Q ') #'* ), "$0) (( #* "$ #K 1Q ') $! " )(; ( F# ' # K $! " #* F J $ Q ') $! ")&( $ +Q ') J 6Q ') #! ")( # # 0( " J 9)( ') "#? # J (( #! " " " $, "$ 0) +Q 6Q H C " ') # $ 0 '#? #"J! "" ' "$ /=Q1Q ') 4 BA'0 " (( & "? # 9 ( 0 3 "( # # K " 1 0 O J C"J< 'J&) " 1

33 4 33! " #? ''# ) #+Q ') 'B(((@ 4 33 "J$ $ 4()"> ;$) +Q $ ')! "#? ''# $ J ') /+Q ((!? ""9 (&#' ') 0 3'' #3 1+/ " $ &$. CA#" 0" ( ( * CA#; "<" (6Q ') J "( 9#3 '1Q J 3 B'/7Q " B ++Q #* "#0 $ $ 9) 0) H"$ +Q ') 0) & #J (=Q 9) H BA, &$ )! ";=Q $ ' ) J )! " "$ J #@ 7Q ') 0), 4$! " ') 4 BA' # A ') $' ' ') ') & "" 4$ C ; * # ') $ >")( ")" & "#9)(# 9)( 9) $ (@! ".$ CA# < '"3 J +Q ') ) " 0$ & " =

34 &$&$+ " IJ $ 3$ # J $ # ') "J#0$ (@! "" C * 9) '! "& "# ( #B(." A ') 4 )" Q ') J '& " $ J#C (@! ""$ #",! "? "$ 0) #- ### * )? '## "#J ') 0)! " $ I@' # $ 'B $' ') $ '& "(@ C J$? #J "" # # $ ' (@ J $ # ') #? # $.((' " ' #A# & "M# "A(0 (! "? ') $ ( ') " $ '- <'J0 $ C#(# )")'>? 3 )) $ * ') ') ## 10 (@ <@ 9) $ 3 4$ ## H >J$ J$ '' # '( $ $0( 0 ( #. $ ' " J $ "J)#&(F'.)" 0( 6

35 & # 4 #@ & 9$ $ 'B4 (@ "'@(0 H ") 'J # 0) 0 ( ) "#? J $ ' #< 33O J C"J< '&) BA N&( $ ' ( 9#3( $ *3*'78!''! &$+$' % " 4. #,#( &$+$( (@ (<) 33; 3 J $(J3 K J (J"$( C#'JH $( C" D9#J-* ) #"E & J< J. ) $( $( I # $ &M, J' ' C J.()A 0 (' (.$>)'.:# ' ).$ 3 ) (0( 1, ) <.:# ' F 2 (@ $ "# 3 6& 9$ # #,#? # &M ""J $ 0( "$.33 (@ - ## # 7

36 < #3 #& # 2&? $ F.:# ' $)J ' D EJ -#$ # ## >.:# ' D.:# # # (0 G #D ( ( E$ - &K # F () * ) "J " (( &3 3 " (( ""$& 3 () & G. (0 G$(@ 4 33 ) # (@ J9, )J< <) 33(( " $ &#9 '@ 9 () $. $ 3 $ D$GE$D$"E ; $G#(F ##K J'& <) 33 $ $" $ () K <) 33# -$ () K <) 33 #&'(@ 4# () J <) 33& $ JJ <) 33 ## ' T() 8 2&$ U-$. $ #9.O 0 $. 9#K 77 ## 0 9B 9 ('

37 &$+$& *# # K 77 $ (@ ) () #" ). B &" ( $ # # ( #H;$) <) 33 & GQ($J$ (@ <) 33C" 77& G#16Q J#K (@ 6Q 1 ' A 3"(, ; ) & G C) =Q< 6Q C0'($$$ #C"<) 3 3 (H Q () ' & # B #" " $ J # ' () 3"( D. 6Q & <) 33C"$ () &(C 7 K )#)A $ -$ $ &4 (@ "$ # ( '0 ("$ C" 3 B C" J C" " J 'J 3 ' >)''# & ( C" (<' I3 #$ ("$ ' " K & 4 (@ Q = 6 <"? # + 1 I3 # + = C# 1 0"#) #J & G7Q

38 0 (H 6 <#)? #? # ' 6 & C" &$+$+ ) $ '# () 333"( ( < <@ 0 C" ( (&;D9< J 3 ' J ' 0 ( "# $ ' $ '- )'# ":# 0 # " E 9 ; + (A## 4 & ' C" N&( &" P (@ K 77 J$ * # ##J#.$' " K ("" $ $0$ '? " "'@(.$' C"". 'B 4 J #."? " $ ( $ 0( < (; )#& $D, 'E 3 ; " #'$) $ J ( 0 ( # 9# J A. #J($ ') &$. " $ 0!20*

39 $!#!" $ #<$ ")" & ""$' $ J #4 3." >( #&-) $ J$ >/?"' &".$' - 3)"#<9## ""$ 0$ (@ <( - (@ * 3)" -*.$' &" () #J $ &" #J $ 0 #'# (-& I)# J $ # -, ) $ F$ (@ C"? C?? " & ""$'$ I) "'## I! J 0) "'## 0! # 0#" * (@ 9 ")C$! "'## $ J $4 (@ (@ ( # 0 D> (@ ##! "'## EJ )"#$ G.)"J#LC## # ( $ #*! "'## $,#. 0 ( #@! " 3 I!#""))! "J 0 ( '###I) "'## 3(! "". #J$$ #3 0) ")!?"$ )! " "#F$0

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

41 $ +$($' & " 3 J B " 0 ## 3$$ && /K & "B<& "& $ ' >)'J$ (-#>$ (J#! " & $ &# $ I ' $#I$ & $! "J#&)$J"# (J $ J $ &)! "$ $. # (. 0 ( F$ 0B J # 0 &33 < " ')&@$ ## (J$4$ '($ #3(J ( & "#-3')#?$ #@J &$ & "' 3' 0J <J&, -##('($ J( #( ( C '# I!. ' #B &3' &! " ' ) " >)' #BF"#! " C 3( '## "# I!"# >. J'##", ' "#& & ' ) ">)' " ' )("31!,!,##-". -* " -&" 3)" J"0 $ J - $. # 3, ) ") J$ #.,& '## 2 0) # 9" -)" $ ' 9 &) ( /

42 #B.$' - 0$ F 3". " J - 3)" " "# # #? " ' /=/?)" " $ # ( ( K ( 4# " $ "'##3")0) '#3 Studienplätze (Sommersemester + nachfolgendes Wintersemester) &;.$' 3)"#<9##" #&" 0$ 3 3"JC" 3 )( "J$ M3 "M' * ( "K K - 0$ $ #"('#( # (C"3 $ 1

43 Bewerber je Studienplatz &;.$' - 0$ F3)"#<9## " $($( #<$ (@ &).$' 4 #" 0@ "&( 7 "J 777( # H 6 3!!!74!@3 A8 #2" ""2-16== / 66 - =+/ /== =1/6 / =7/+ = 71 -$ 6// /7= 7/1/ -% =/7 -& 6/ = -) 61= /+ 771= -- 6/7 /=+ 7=11/ -- 6+= 6==B 76/== /= 7=/ =

44 +$($& --$ 6=/= --% 6+7/6 --& 6+= --) # V77-(@ 0) 0 >;.$' &" #<9##"!. /!""0 -"1, ) -. ## ' J "# C 9 J H## ' A. ## ' J ((, ) J@'#.:# ' 4 ('.$' -76 & # # $ - (@ 4# J 3 - (@ Entwicklung der Studierendenzahlen im ersten Fach- und Hochschulsemester Studierende im ersten Hochschulsemester Studierende im ersten Fachsemester &+;.$' "# <9 # #<9##" 6

45 '(&"() (' 3)"" #<$ -. # C" -J ' "$- &##" $ ##(@ K (@ K 0 ##* "- #- # C 8 ',7D3 (! / +/7 V770) 0 D-E " (. (. # -(@ 76/$ ( >;.$'< # #<9##"J0 0 #.$' -. # #.$' - 9##" #J() #&3'(;- # ()@ - #77 = J$) -. # 6 &. # 77 Q(@ 1Q CB. ') )" (@.$''B3$&" * #2" ""2-1= = /+/ = = $ 716 +/ ++ -% 7 -& 76 += ) 1= / /+ =+ +6/ = += ==/ + = C&#&776#7#1 7

46 Anteil Erstsemester (FS) an Studierende insgesamt (in %) 18,00% 16,00% 14,00% 12,00% 10,00% 8,00% 6,00% 4,00% 2,00% 0,00% &/;.$'&. # # #<9##" <@ 0'(.$' -. # $) ( &" J DG E < J # 9##" $< $ J & " #BJ - N $.$' " -$ 9'"94 J&" J B # J 3 #, )" J 0#'##, ) C3( 7 & # 4 0# * B(( ## " N <@ ) # +2/ 3, )$ $ # $ 33" (J#B "J$ 3$ # ## # M, ) $ 3 ". ( $ 77 6 C&# (@@'77+#J77=#++1# 7 >(&( #/&+0#(@ # 7772". G)3 ( +

47 +$($+ #!0" #" 1 ##".$' $? # # <9##"' I)# "$ C??$ 8$(, ) I)# $ (F J#K "# T &( 0 #BJ & &" ' " (( ""$, ) C??'##; # C"##BJ C" # ":# ' "### 3) $, )D&E(@. " ' ' C?? )(@ (( " 3 ; ( <@ K "# &$ ( P 0) J0# 0( I)# # 0 #&" "K "M' * ( ' " K $ 77J # K # B&" J& " &#&#K 771'## -""K ##="$ Q(66/(3 #HF) & C 6 K H&, )9 ' "#>"J ## :# ' ( $#6=+ +

48 Entwicklung der Anzahl der Absolventen &1;.$' &" ( &) #. # ') ) &( 7 K F) &" J ' JQ "+ <@ 0$ < J -& 9##"(@ 3) ) "0 ( $ "$ $ #I( # J#- () - $ 3' 0 # C 6 K $J#&$ '"$$ 0" ( # " " K $ " 'B; "# 3"' # "# 77 0 # &" 77J #@() "# 76= ((@ $ " J &" "$ 77 77=( '(&"< # 1=K &(()FJ & &" # <# #K 77#&& ' 3""C??J$" K? :#>=#& J ') +

49 "$ 3 &"77( J#-3'(#- Vergleich der Anzahl Studierende im ersten Fachsemester und Anzahl von Absolventen 14 Semester später Studierende im ersten Fachsemester Absolventen 14 Semester später &=;* &" # <# &" &+# 3) ". $ < #'-## "$ &"<. # ' ##?'0"(* ' " #J$ #3 A(77 "0# ' J $ )'* '# 093) J!"J M#'# 0 <@ C"&'(0#"$ # # &#A $ 3$ (@ "$(J ( * $ 0"( 'B "##($ $ ;!! C ' - / 1= 61 - /== /+/ / = +6 -$ /7= +/ +

50 -% +11 = -& 11 +=1 +7 -) 6 / 7-7/+ = /=+ 6= / --B 6== ==/ -- ++/= 77/ -- =7 7 0# V770) 0 >+;.$' J-&" 0) - $. ') * D$E@ " / K " D$GE 1QA'331Q A #"# # $G (#"M'* ( Entwicklung des Verhältnisses von Absolventen zu Erstsemestern 1,2 1,0 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0, Jahr Verhältnis Studienabschlüsse zu Erstsemestern (Fachsemester) &6;.$' $G#<9##" Durchschnittswert & ' ) J $ #4#" 'J$) &" 3)"$;#B 3 $) J &0 (0 +# $ C$ ">" ++

51 - & & " $GQ- &'##3 9 J &" FJ 9##"# J 77 ' 16Q ( 7Q J # ( # $ H$ " " (<' ; (. ) $ 0 # 9# #4"" # <# 9 #9'(< G* #"$ " 3)" " #3 $ " #" H$ ) < ( 0 # (? ## < 9##" >#& J)(JF) &" C" J 3 F' (@ ( AJK #=$ AJ4 # 9 J$@ $G)A +/

52 Anzahl an bestandenen Promotionen &7;.$' &"? # &"$? # 77'+JQ ( +1JQ # K ## $ 9)(? # #J $? )"##"$ &( 6 K &$&Q (/Q@ - $& ##K - #)##& A #"@ "/K J $ &. # 3) &' (@!!, '@!!, ' 76 +J7Q 766 +J7Q 76 +J1Q 767 +J+Q 76 +/J1Q 77 ++JQ 76+ +/J6Q 77 +J/Q 76/ +/JQ 77 ++J/Q 761 +J6Q 77 +/J/Q 76= ++J7Q 77+ +/J7Q J+Q 77/ +/J+Q 767 +/JQ 771 +/JQ 77 +JQ 77= +/JQ 77 +1JQ 776 +/JQ 77 +1JQ J=Q +1

53 77 +6JQ +=J+Q JQ /JQ 77/ /J/Q /JQ 771 /J7Q " $%EF $%EF >/;.$'$&. # 3) & $. #.$' F@ # (@!! 77= , /J=Q /+JQ /=JQ 1J1Q 1JQ 1JQ >1;.$'&$. # 77= # >" ( J ' (@ ) K # # $ & & $ $ #(0/ '(@ ()! " 0! (! "J 0 ( I) "'## # I) "'## ) #( "# (C '#>)'# '#( &)! "$ #0# (J B 'J >)' J J 779 ' (( " 4J & 4" #B.,2.0@ 'BF."$< 4$ '& '&33 JH.,2.0@ S0) " 0 ( J )""( ( ) $ ' &33 ' H.,0@ +=

54 .$' - )! " # & "J &" K 77 ') $HJ0M -)! " B&")! " 0) 0 # 33J # FH(@(C)! "$ 0) "## (( " 0"(? ') ( ''00 # ( F) &@ 3 & ') * 9 $! " #& "$ (?( 3""#' H$###' "# 'J H$ * ) " ' ' J "# BA> ') "J@ $ < "# '#.3)##0 $) ) ' ' # ) 0 "# & $ 3 ( &" (@ H$#) ' $' "#(@ K 776 $ J H$ # #0 " 1Q ') " O Q "* ) "$ &"$*? : /Q ) "* 0? ) " J W(( J " 9"" $)! "J #& '#0 '## #- -)- & )@ JA@ 0 F) " B#' )(@'@@ & ""## 0 " # B# 4 (' +6

55 Absolventen der Humanmedizin Ausländische Ärzte Approbation Berufserlaubnis Approbation Berufserlaubnis Stationäre Versorgung Ambulante Versorgung Andere Bereiche und Ausland Ruhestand &;-&(# ) #* +$&$' * # 9 $) ' $) #)A $@$ * " (@ $) J (@ 0 $ "(( $ 'B " ( # (@ ' )( J&( ")" B ( # $ # # #B,,# C,# # (," # K 0#. F) &33 ; "#J( $ J"# J ' " 4 (@ 33 0B " &33 C" B "# $. 3 ## #'. (#. 0# 3 + -$ " I)# " 0 0 J 9 - &33 J# '## J - + >(&'(0# +7

56 +$&$( 0) JJ" J$ #)A #* 0) K ) <)$ "#&33 0 ( "##")J $ # & " I)# 0# "&33 I ) "'## (33.&( I) "'## )"#B$) >JC" #$) P )#' M# J0& $ & "I) " '## 3 " J3 "3 - F! " J I) "'## #! " "# 03J &33 #& J$) - 3 ) 2 -"!? I) "'##.#BJ.$' " " J J $<!?)> A J$ $ 8 #. )'J (@ & J ( 0 ( & " 0 ( J# " )! "'## # #-3' )# ) # &?J '(J#@D E # C ' "J &?J 3$, () & "#&?) ">)' 3 #J C (!?) ## 'C3((@! ") " >)' 0 # -J" J # # =/7 /

57 Entwicklung der Anzahl von ÄiP ÄiP in Deutschland &;.$' &"!? davon ÄiP ohne ärztliche Tätigkeit #4""&"!?) ">)'& ( 7 )#)A'# #* "&"K!?- K B ' 3" ) #"# #J!?"#>D33E")$ J$? ''#6 C #' &? ' "$ K ( <@ K 3$ A -!?=+1!?# # 2J## # # $ A>### # ># # 2+#K #(! "J &?? "$ 1 (* )!?"&K ;!'G!3!! 1H+A 1H+' J/ / -- 6+/= // J= / 6/+ J7 -- 7/77 17 J1 / (A# #J# K.(@ 6#&??'!?33")$ #' /

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

59 * # - # &" F$K ".$'-&( 7 K $ &" -) &??B &" & 771 #&# K ## $!?&.$' (J * ## # & &?? Entwicklung berechneter Zugang ÄiP im Vergleich zu Anzahl an Absolventen nach durchschnittlicher Studiendauer &;.$' -!?#* "&"&. * )&H")#&? 3 ; 6 # # '##3"#. J&"&J &?? J " K ## & " &" &J # 3! "'## #,' J $ & &??,# - &) #!? " J #@ # ## &(# >)'&?@ $ H&'( I) "'## 8(! " C3( '## 8 J $ F B(( 00 ( '. ') (@ 4# "!?&>J-"!?J /

60 ! "'## #J776''J$) &"!?J ') Entwicklung von ÄiP Studienabschlüsse nach Regelstudienzeit ÄiP insgesamt Zugang ÄiP &;* &" &?## &" -) "#&?$ &"& +$&$& P, 'B(0. ' * # $ 03$'B* )# C 3(3J ) # K ) J & ' >" &( 7 K ' -$! "" ""J # &! ") " >)' 776Q! ") ">) 'JJ=Q /+

61 Entwicklung von Arztzahlen in Deutschland Ärzte insgesamt Ohne ärztliche Tätigkeit Berufstätige Ärzte &+;.$' & "" 0 # &" ()! " ) J" J * )#) )! ""K '#." 4 A! " 7Q ) #3 =Q$ 0 $0B JB 3 ( 0 ) Berufstätige Ärzte Berufstätige Ärzte Stationär tätig In Behörden/Körperschaften u. a. In anderen Bereichen Ambulant tätig &/;.$' &" ()! J &!?- &"! "$ 3 //

62 +$&$+ +$&$5 4# 0"22,"! 1 " &"! " :3" $ (0 &#J & ") " (J. $ &# #-## J )" # ' ( 0 (@ - '' 4 #,#' J" (! " A(@ ' &(0 &#$ &"! " F '0"$ 0 # ( 0 '' 'B &") " >)' $ >) ' J $# 0! ""#-3' ( &(# 0 ( J) -AJ$! "$ < "$ (3;+ $ J$ #$ 4 ' $ J ' 3' C' I) "'## $ 0 "# -3' 4 '! "'## '( J $ 4 ' $. &"& '##<J#<' " #J#$) J0 J$$&( # * ( 9@ J! "" J#' M# "J( #B 4# #" 3 # - 4 'I3;++ - & ' 77/. $ (J#<& ##"77(@ K CB',#! " 4""#&##" - ##K 77/#* ". /1

63 +$&$6 '##" #. J - 4 ' 8 $ & ' " &##" $ 8 #3( & B 0 (" #( J 9$(<' #"@ ( 'B " */ 7#!.$' - ' )! " >)' J4""$> $ 3' " JJ4& 8#. )' #B&'-" ' 0 ()' # (( " $ H#B.$' -! " 7# ' >)'I) "'##. ( "$!"!? : J 4 J C"F J& 8? #"2& #"J ) ">)'!"! J 9J (( #J J. "J (()J& "J 4 #)A $ - "! " ) ">)' > "* & ' ( I! "# > ;")#>)'I!" D) " >)'EJ $) >)' I!" D) ">)'EB.03 4 )'J ) " >)' J $) " B $ J $) (( #J ) " >)'J ( # $ "# D$E "J $' CB'" P &A ##@ ;#& ") ">)' I) " ## # I) J /=

64 F & "J) ") J##&#4 ) '. "@ -! ") ">) '# H. ( I!3$ & 3' "! " A ' ) " >)'; J).:'&' ) DCE! "J(@ & F * ) $ ##! " C3( J,'. & 0) "'## 3(@.+. * B((.$' - ' )J33! " JI) "'## #. (( "! "!"! ( #(@ & $ (; 100/7H8 # /+ 1J= 0 (() J6 J6 < 3 & " J+ J &A#9) /J1 1J 0 (( #) J/ J6. " /J= 1J & J6 J 6J 6J N;0) "'## >7;>)'! ") ">)' E H((@ &3',' D$E $ J - # $! "'## H #K (0# '$, -# H " ) 3 # $ * B(( ) -$ $.&3' (@ J & #* 3 $ 'BJ"-! "I- (@ /6

65 +$&$8 & #-&* '-! "776 '? "J<) "? "J $*)( * $ -&*)( >"B J & '& '! " # $ 3 0 (@ & ; C" & &?? & $ J J! "3 0&## $. ') $ '' 3"# C! "J #B $ ## #J $. " ( #)A##J$ $ (@ $ &.$' - #& )! " ) # # # 9 ( ) C$ ## $ C! "4 I#0) 'B! "#&( $C ## & $ # B # C J & C #BJ& "! " " (J $ $ $ 02 0" $ J $# ' ( $ J (' 4 BA &$ & " " (@ J #)A & ' -&* & G 9##" # C ' "$? " J # G *)( -&* + 0<) " (@ K & G Q -&*+;/1(( & ' 3"" '"$#< & J #1Q$B &0 ()J '336Q#K #"J(#& # 'H(! " 03$$ & & )# #K ') #1Q B K " //Q & &? :( ;1QJ;Q H(? $ ( /7

66 +$&$9 J! "# # 0 A ' ) " 0 ()' $ I - H( &'( -&*#J/Q- " 3(0)( = ) ' - ()! " &#3# $ 1=6! "")J 3( >)' (J 17/ < $ 6 Q& ') J/J/ Q! "# 0 J$ JQ 3 0 4$J "0 $ J J+ Q ( 0 B(( * $ 33 Q $. "$J $ 0 &#J)(J1Q! $O#? #" 8 $ J Q. <.$'0* )* $! ")(J1Q & 0 J ##9#' $! " J$' &"J)(,, " " 0 (3 3' #' ) " 0 $ # 0 O J C"J?M 2?M 3 & ##" <) ""(( $ < & J $"0 ' 4M)' 4 0)(#B' # ' 0 # &J #'J4 A J< ' H & 0)(#B'? #" C"' C"( #'J,#$#"J 4 ##? 9 $ 0 J & # '( ( ##"#0 ( = -&* (" 3(0)( 'B! "A ' ) " >)' ' ($ J " 3(0)(< ( )$ ( 1

67 $$ C( &M0$ #"J"# > ( #" & "" 0 & "J $ "$ " ($ -##( ) (J (@ '@ 0 (! " # #-## ' & ' >)' (0 $@$ $) ; P ) "$ # &33 "$ &33 0 ()' &$! "&.$' -. # JDG E < 0 0 &M #( # ; - #()@ - # 77 6 J$) -. # 7 &. # 77Q(@ 1Q CB. ') )"(@.$''B 3$ &" * & &"& &( 6 K &$& Q ( - $ & # # K - #) ##&A "/ K J $&. # 3) & ' & $. # "K (@ 1Q 0 ) " K "M' * ( ' " 6 C&#&776#7#1 7 C&# (@@'77+#J77=#++1# 1

68 K $ 77J#K # B &" &" & #&#K 771'## -""K #Q( 0!? '-"" " #( -"JI) "'## ' $ #0!?' ') $ CB, 'B* )# C3( # K ) J.4 (@ '3$& ' -! ""K ' $.)(J@') J& &?- & "" 1

69 %! # % -##(@ " 0$ $ J $$ ( 0 > "$:! "#"$ '#< $ ## J$, & (@! "# $ 9 M & CB'")"J3" )* "(0 " * (@@ 3#B C(3""!19 & -##(@ "''! " # "$ 3 " $ & ' 0*20!J $ J 3', J.$ ')K ) '$, '" I(). C! " $ (@ ) "* $(@ ) 0 ' 3 $ 0*20! (J, #) "0 0) < "3 #? :J ) "* J(#"('H( & #0$ )"' J "3 #' 0) <.:'N(" " &3'.((' $@ & "# #'@( 0 ( (( " #J "6Q ') 0)? #J((""I 9 ' ') $ # 1 (@ 33! " " ##'? (@ '##K. # C#(# 0 ( $ ) '' 1

70 $ &" ((&, #'$ &$! " $0) ' $#3" (J3', ")'&"! "# J # <'! "J F< P. :' N( " <'"$ ''@(, 0 ( 0 C #B # 9' (? ()' ("J? #'! "#J (( <' ' 0 (" "$ 0 $ *# $ 0 (! " * (@ ) K ( * #9 3 " # (.$' * ) 3 " # 4$ ( &! "(@ ' 0 #B &, (@ #B $ ( ) "? (, 3 3' ( " (. J& $ $! " ') $ 0) ( $ > A(< ' 0 (@, ( ' & ## < H & ') & # & ') # I#, ( " $ * # (>)' -" #@ #&# P " ( ' J$ $" J < "#B'J' & " (? 3'.? # " $. ' & CB'J $ "( J 1+

71 .! "# ') 3 & '! "(! "# ( & # # H$# $ # J(@ C" " K ' ( & " ' >)' ' (J! "J ' )$ J ) '#' M #3;= $# :3" (J &C" A '? : ' # 7Q 0 # "###&"J J ' (& $) #"$ ' " ' ($ &(0 >$3.#3( #3(." ' )# 0B' 3.$' CA #(I)?' -#<' M#M $ * # 9 & C" #3 ( (( ' ". #B * ' <# 0 ( $"$ ( (@ < J ' >)' (#) <@ 4$ CA# $( CA#' " I) 0 >@ &0 # & (@ # ''.#3( 0 0 J <B H* ) ". #) $ " ( # "$ &B3( CB' 3( 3 :) & ' & 0@ ' J # # ( H$# " 0"@! #3(J ' # " ((J #! "$ (@ ' >)'"$ &#4 0( $ #"$>4 1/

72 % 5$($' (" 3 )# # 4$ " < 'J ()' * $ '# 'J"#" 0"$" * (3"( C"& "3' " 'J<'"' "$" # * # #9 #-C"! "# ' $ J "- 3)" J # '@( * ' 0 ( <# C >")( "$) & ($) #B $# B &G ' >)'" # < J! ")"$ J'BF(# #C >")( $ ' J # #! "! " B $@ J # # $ #@J# >" "" #&#A ) "$ 0 ( ' )! " # ")" ( & ' )! " J # < ' $ J $$ ( 0 # " )? 0 ( &#B 6I'!#!(1! 0 +!9." )?.$' & 0 (! "A#LC# 3 C& #* "$) * (@ '3 # -## 4 (0 2# # 9' ( &! " ") ("J $> J#'#& #<9##"""; 11